I don’t usually write about issues related to my fan fiction and participation in the world of fandom on this journal. It’s always dealt more with my personal life but there’s been a certain overlap lately. Basically, the recent controversy about Livejournals suspension of users for posting sexually explicit fan art is making me take a look at the role fandom has come to play in my life and what my shadow career as a fan fiction writer means to me.
I’ve been closely following several communities related to the controversy and a few days ago I came across an article called “The Terrible Secret of Livejournal” by Matthew Skala. Written in a tone of authority, this essay basically said that fandom material is against the law to start with and that writers and artists should be glad that Livejournal and their parent company Six Apart allow it and therefore should not give them grief. That any kind of sexually explicit material involving minor characters is illegal to create or possess and that that’s the law and anyone who thinks otherwise is “confusing one’s wishes with the law.” And also all the normal people out there think people who write fan fiction and draw fan art are creepy perverts anyways.
For all the unwavering certainty with which it is written, many of Skala’s points can be refuted. I know I’ve seen documentation that fan fiction and fan art are not against the law so long as their source is acknowledged and they aren’t used for commercial purposes. Further, the statement that any sexually explicit work concerning underage characters (let me stress, not actors or actual people but characters) can be considered child pornography can’t be true either. . I’m no expert of pornography, but in my small collection there’s a graphic novel called The Young Witches, by Solana Lopez. It involves schoolgirls who are definitely under 18 yet as far as I know The Young Witches, published by the Seattle passed Eros Comix has been in print and avalaible to the public since 1993. You can get it on amazon.com.
But enough on the legalities. My brother’s the lawyer in our family. I’m the basketcase. This isn’t about the law, it’s about me feeling crummy about myself as usual.
In “The Terrible Secret of Livejournal” Skala uses words like “delusional”, “whining” and “irrational” and “unreasonable” to describe any sort of questioning of or speaking out against the suspensions and censorship. Skala apparently isn’t the only one who feels this way. I’ve seen his opinion mirrored, to a lesser degree, in several personal journals. Increasingly over the past few days, I’ve felt stupid and hysterical for being so upset by Livejournals actions and for allowing myself to get so bogged down in the controversy. I can’t help wondering why I’m taking all this so personally. I really wonder if I’ve become too invested in my on-line persona and my fan fiction writing.
Intellectually, fan fiction is exactly the thing that fascinates me. I’ve always been interested in the idea twisted retellings, Snow White or the Wizard of Oz from the point of view of the witch. Jayne Eyre as seen by the madwoman in the attic, Gone With the Wind through the eyes of the slave (here I refer to Alice Randall’s controversial novel The Wind Done Gone). Further I’m also interested in the way people interact with text, incorporating the stories they consume into their own story. In my dreams, there are frequent appearances by characters from the television series Charmed and Buffy the Vampire Slayer. It’s almost as if characters take root in each person’s subconscious, enter into their dreams. When I was growing up, my sister and I made paper dolls based on every superhero we knew of, hundreds of them each only and inch tall. With these characters we created elaborate on-going stories of our own. In a way, I see fan fiction as a grown up version of our childhood games. A form of what Diane Ackerman would call “deep play”.
And that’s just the pseudo-intellectual side of my brain. Emotionally, fan fiction has provided me with something I never had before as a writer-- an audience. Making the decision to put my work forward before this audience hasn’t been easy and I’ve gotten a couple devastating smack downs since I posted my first story back in April of 2006 but mainly it’s been a really positive experience for me to know people are reading and enjoying the stuff I write. When I went to my parents in New York last week I was looking through my old papers. There was so much there-- whole novels, an 18 year olds attempt at metaphysical fantasy ala Sandman, dozens and dozens of stores written between the ages of 14 and 32. Most of it’s never been read. Most of it’s withered on the vine.
Maybe it’s no wonder I take this whole thing too personally. I haven’t gotten a whole lot of positive reinforcement in my life.
Fan Fiction posted on the internet isn’t supposed to have any value. It’s supposed to be a hobby at best, a sick obsession at worst. It’s amateur, illegitimate, throw away. But didn’t a lot of things with value start out that way? Things like comic strips and later comic books, the first musical recordings? Maybe someday the value of the kind of writing I’ve been doing on-line will be evident to the people Matthew Skala calls “John and Mary Whitebread”. Until then I have to go by my own, unvalidated belief that it has value which for me is the hardest thing in the world. Other people’s opinions have always meant a great deal to me. I don’t want anyone to think I’m annoying or out of line. It makes me sick to think that somewhere someone thinks I’m pathetic or stupid. How do you believe yourself and not all the people out there who really know what they’re talking about?
P.S. My icon for this post is Luna Lovegood because I think I need to start modeling myself on her.